Manuscript Evaluation Process

Manuscript Evaluation Process

Turkish Journal of Geriatrics is indexed in the Web of Science (WoS) Core Collection, including the Science Citation Index Expanded (SCIE) and the Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI), as well as Scopus and TÜBİTAK ULAKBİM TR Dizin.

All manuscripts submitted to the journal undergo a rigorous multi-stage evaluation process in accordance with the principles of scientific publishing, international publication ethics, and the journal's editorial policies. Following submission, manuscripts proceed through the following stages:

1. Submission Registration

The manuscript and all accompanying documents uploaded by the author(s) are registered in the online submission system, and a unique manuscript identification number is assigned.

2. Technical and Administrative Preliminary Review

The Editorial Office examines the submission to verify:

  • The completeness of all uploaded files
  • The accuracy of author and correspondence information
  • The presence of all required forms and ethical approval documents
  • Compliance with the journal's Instructions for Authors
  • Reference formatting and general manuscript presentation.

3. Technical Revision Request (When Required)

If technical deficiencies or non-compliance with journal requirements are identified, the manuscript is returned to the author(s) for correction. Manuscripts that have not been revised in accordance with the journal's technical requirements and submission guidelines cannot proceed to the scientific peer-review stage.

4. Similarity (Plagiarism) Screening

Manuscripts that successfully pass the technical review are subjected to similarity screening. In cases where an excessive similarity rate or potential concerns regarding publication ethics are identified, the manuscript may be rejected without external review, or the authors may be asked to provide clarification and/or submit revisions.

5. Editorial Preliminary Assessment

The Editorial Board evaluates the manuscript with regard to:

  • Relevance to the journal's scope and aims
  • Scientific originality
  • Timeliness and significance
  • Methodological rigor
  • Potential contribution to the existing literature.

6. Peer-Review Process

Manuscripts that successfully pass the editorial preliminary assessment are assigned to independent expert reviewers in the relevant field. The review process is conducted in accordance with the journal's double-blind peer-review policy, whereby both authors and reviewers remain anonymous throughout the review process.

7. Evaluation of Reviewer Reports

Reviewer reports are carefully assessed by the editors. Based on the reviewers' recommendations, one of the following editorial decisions may be reached:

  • Acceptance
  • Minor Revision
  • Major Revision
  • Rejection.

8. Revision Process

When revisions are requested, authors are required to:

  • Provide a detailed point-by-point response to all reviewer and editor comments
  • Clearly indicate all modifications made to the manuscript
  • Upload the revised files within the specified deadline.

9. Final Editorial Decision

Following evaluation of the revised manuscript by the editors and, when necessary, by the reviewers, a final editorial decision is made. The decision of the Editorial Board is final. Scientific quality, editorial independence, and publication ethics constitute the fundamental principles guiding all stages of the publication process.

10. Copyediting, Proofreading, and Publication

Accepted manuscripts undergo:

  • Language and formatting review
  • Typesetting and page layout preparation
  • Final author proof approval.

Following completion of these stages, manuscripts are scheduled for publication and published electronically in the appropriate issue.

Important Notes

1. Technical Compliance

All deficiencies identified during the technical review stage must be fully addressed before a manuscript can be considered for scientific peer review. Successful completion of the technical review does not imply scientific acceptance of the manuscript; it merely indicates that the submission is eligible to proceed to external peer review.

2. Submission/Application Fee

Regarding manuscript submission fees, the journal adheres to the principles stated by the Interuniversity Council of Türkiye (ÜAK). According to the official statement of ÜAK, journals that "charge a fee at the time of manuscript submission, independently of the editorial decision and regardless of whether the manuscript is accepted or rejected" may be used in academic promotion and performance evaluation applications. Accordingly, the manuscript submission/application fee charged by the journal is solely intended to support the management of editorial and peer-review processes and is entirely independent of the outcome of the scientific evaluation. Payment of the submission fee neither guarantees acceptance nor influences editorial decisions in any manner. Submission fee is non-refundable and has no influence on editorial decisions, peer-review outcomes, or publication acceptance.